Graduation desserts should be simple, weatherproof-ish, delicious and low stress. Because while graduation celebrations are joyful, they’re also challenging in the “someone forgot the folding tables and your cousin is texting that he’s bringing six extra people” kind of way.
This is not the moment to attempt a complicated plated dessert you saw in a fancy food magazine at 11 p.m.
Jump to:
Graduation parties need desserts that can sit out for a while, survive warm weather, feed a crowd and still taste good after Uncle Mike leaves the brownie tray uncovered for 45 minutes.
These are my favorite easy graduation dessert ideas for feeding a crowd without losing your mind.
1. Cookies
Cookies are the MVP of graduation desserts.
They’re portable, easy to stack on trays, easy to make ahead and they can sit out for hours without someone reporting you to the city code enforcement officer.
Chocolate chip cookies, sugar cookies, cake mix cookies, sprinkle cookies, brownies disguised as cookies, these are all good.
People grab cookies. Especially teenagers. They wander by the dessert table 14 times and take “just one more.”
2. Brownies
Did I mention brownies?
Because brownies deserve their own category.
They’re sturdy, crowd-pleasing and almost impossible to screw up if you use a recipe you already know works. Also, see 12 ways to dress up boxed brownie mix for ideas.
You can cut them small to feed a crowd or giant.
Frosted brownies, brownies with candy mixed in, brownie bites, boxed brownies — this is a judgment-free zone.
3. Rice Krispie Treats
Rice Krispie Treats are basically indestructible.
You can make classic Rice Krispie Treats or go wild with sprinkles, chocolate drizzle, peanut butter, Oreos or the graduate’s school colors.
They travel well. They don’t need refrigeration. They survive children. They survive six months in a forgotten lunch bag and most natural disasters.
You could make sheet pan crispy rice treats and divide into sections to make different flavors.
4. Congo Bars
Congo bars are one of the most underrated desserts on the planet.
They’re chewy cookie bars packed with brown sugar goodness, walnuts and chocolate chips and they hold up beautifully on dessert tables.
I think I’ve told this story before, but my grandmother used to mail Congo bars to my uncle when he was serving in Vietnam because they traveled so well.
That’s not a dessert. That’s durability testing.
5. Lemon Bars
Lemon bars are always one of the first desserts to disappear.
Now, they can’t sit outside in the blazing sun all afternoon like a cookie tray can, but there’s an easy workaround.
They make these fancy serving trays now with compartments underneath for ice packs or crushed ice. You can put the lemon bars out after the meal, leave them out for an hour or two, then pop the extras back into the fridge.
6. Dessert Snack Mix
You know, Basic White Trash.
White chocolate snack mix. Puppy chow. White trash mix. Chocolate-covered cereal and pretzels and peanuts and M&Ms thrown together in glorious sugary chaos.
And they’re perfect for graduation parties because you can customize the colors to match the graduate’s school colors.
Add colored M&Ms or sprinkles and suddenly you look organized and festive.
7. Ice Cream Sandwiches
Not everything needs to be homemade.
You could absolutely buy a giant box of ice cream sandwiches from Sam’s Club and call it a day. Frankly, people would still be thrilled.
But if you want to make it feel a little more special, roll the edges in sprinkles or mini chocolate chips and put out toppings so people can decorate their own.
8. Build-Your-Own Sundae Bar
Teenagers and kids love a sundae bar and so does middle-aged me.
Set out tubs of ice cream, sauces, whipped cream, crushed cookies, sprinkles and candy toppings and let people get creative.
This is also one of those desserts that looks way fancier than it actually is.
You’re basically just opening containers and pretending you hosted a Food Network competition.
9. Fancy Fruit Trays
Fruit is always a good idea because eventually someone at the party starts pretending they’re “being healthy” after eating four brownies.
Skip the sad grocery store fruit tray if you can.
A watermelon cut in half and filled with strawberries, pineapple, grapes and watermelon chunks looks impressive with almost no effort.
It’s colorful, refreshing and balances out the dessert table nicely.
Or you can make fruit skewers. Or even better, set out skewers next to the chopped fruit and let people make their own.
That is if you're sure none of the teenage boys are going to turn them into miniature swords. Ain't nobody got time for the ER on graduation day.
10. Caramel Apple Station
This one is fun if you want something interactive.
Slice apples ahead of time and set out caramel dip, melted chocolate, chopped nuts, miniature pretzels, crushed cookies and sprinkles so people can build their own caramel apple slices or caramel apple nachos as shown in photo above.
It feels a little more special than just setting out another tray of bars, but it’s still incredibly easy.
And unlike full candy apples, nobody risks losing a filling.
11. S'mores Station
A s’mores station is one of those graduation party desserts people remember because it's interactive and fun instead of just another tray of bars.
You can keep it simple with graham crackers, Hershey bars and marshmallows or get fancy with peanut butter cups, flavored or oversized marshmallows or different kinds of chocolate bars.
Graham crackers are absolutely not de rigueur. You can use anything really: crackers, cookies, bread.
See my giant list of alternatives to graham crackers when making s'mores.
If you have a fire pit, great. If not, tabletop s’mores makers work too. I’ve even seen people use Sterno setups for indoor parties.
12. Dessert Nachos
Cinnamon sugar tortilla chips, fruit salsa and maybe a squeeze bottle of chocolate sauce.
13. Chocolate Dipped Pretzel Rods
Chocolate-dipped pretzel rods look fancy but are so easy to make.
Dip pretzel rods (buy in chip aisle at grocery store) in melted chocolate or candy melts, add sprinkles in school colors and let them set on parchment paper or wax paper.
If you want to get fancy, wrap the rods in cellophane and put them in mason jars or vases on the dessert table.
Or if you just can't even, lay them on a platter and save your sanity.
14. Sheet Cakes (Buy One)
And finally: cake.
What graduation dessert table is complete without cake?
But I’m going to say something controversial for a food blogger:
You should probably buy the graduation cake.
I said what I said.
Cakes are tricky. Especially giant cakes. Especially giant cakes you only make once every few years while also trying to host a graduation party.
There are just too many variables.
Cakes sink. Frosting melts. Layers slide.
Suddenly you’re standing in your kitchen staring at what looks like a haunted birdhouse made of buttercream.
And graduation cakes matter because people gather around them. They take pictures. Everybody stares at the cake.
So unless cake decorating is already your thing, go to your favorite grocery store bakery or local bakery and order one.
Just order it ahead of time because graduation season gets wild and so do bakeries.
Also — and I say this with love — if you care deeply about frosting, ask what kind they use before ordering.
Because if you’re envisioning rich buttercream and end up with one of those whipped toppings that tastes like lightly sweetened air, that is a profound emotional disappointment.
Comments
No Comments